Pubblico o privato? | Il sistema sanitario in Germania

Germany, a country in Central Europe, is known for its rich history, vibrant culture, and strong economy. With a population of about 83 million, Germany boasts one of the most comprehensive and efficient healthcare systems in the world.

For expats considering a move to Germany, understanding the healthcare system is crucial. Germany offers a welcoming environment for foreigners, with many attracted by job opportunities in its robust industrial and technological sectors. The German healthcare system, while complex, provides a mix of public and private options that cater to both residents and newcomers.

Germany's healthcare system is based on a dual public-private model, with statutory health insurance (gesetzliche Krankenversicherung or GKV) covering the majority of the population, while private health insurance (private Krankenversicherung or PKV) is available as an option for certain individuals.

The German healthcare system operates across several levels:

• Primary care: Provided by general practitioners (Hausärzte)
• Secondary care: Specialist services in hospitals and clinics
• Tertiary care: Highly specialized treatments in university hospitals and specialized centers

Patients generally have free choice of doctors and can directly access specialists without referrals.

As of 2021, Germany allocated about 12.8% of its GDP to healthcare, one of the highest percentages among OECD countries.

Structure of the Healthcare System in Germany

Public healthcare

The statutory health insurance system (GKV) is the cornerstone of Germany's public healthcare system. It covers about 88% of the population and is funded through contributions from employees and employers, with additional government subsidies.

The GKV is administered by numerous non-profit insurance funds (Krankenkassen), which are self-governing bodies under state supervision. As of 2021, there were 103 statutory health insurance funds in Germany.

The German public healthcare system provides a comprehensive range of services, including:

• GP and specialist visits
• Hospital care
• Preventive services and health check-ups
• Mental health services
• Dental care (with co-payments)
• Prescription medications (with co-payments)
• Rehabilitation services

How to Register for Health Insurance in Germany

To access public healthcare in Germany, individuals need to:

1. Register their residence (Anmeldung) at the local registration office.
2. Choose a statutory health insurance provider (Krankenkasse) and apply for membership.
3. Receive their health insurance card (Gesundheitskarte), which is used to access healthcare services.

Coverage and accessibility

All legal residents of Germany are required to have health insurance. The level of coverage and associated costs in the public system are generally the same for all users, with some exceptions:

1. Employees earning below €66,600 per year (as of 2023) are mandatorily insured in the GKV system.
2. Those earning above this threshold, self-employed individuals, and civil servants can opt for private insurance (PKV) instead.

Accessibility is generally high across Germany, with short waiting times for most services. However, there can be longer waits for certain specialist appointments or elective procedures.

Private healthcare

Private health insurance (PKV) is an option for about 11% of the population in Germany. It offers several advantages:

1. Potentially lower premiums for young, healthy individuals
2. Access to a wider range of services and treatments
3. Shorter waiting times for some specialist appointments
4. Option for single hospital rooms

Major private health insurance providers in Germany include:

• Allianz
• DKV
• Debeka
• Signal Iduna

Pharmacy healthcare

Pharmacies (Apotheken) play a crucial role in German healthcare, providing:

1. Prescription medications
2. Over-the-counter drugs
3. Health advice and consultations
4. Some health screenings (e.g., blood pressure checks)

In Germany, many medications that are available over-the-counter in other countries require a prescription.

Emergency healthcare

Emergency services are available to all in Germany, regardless of insurance status. The national emergency number is 112. Key aspects of emergency healthcare in Germany include:

1. Hospital emergency departments (Notaufnahme)
2. Ambulance services (Rettungsdienst)
3. On-call medical services for non-life-threatening emergencies (ärztlicher Bereitschaftsdienst)
4. Air ambulance services for remote areas or critical cases

In an Emergency

For emergencies in Germany, dial 112. This number connects you to ambulance and fire services. For police, dial 110. In hospitals, emergency departments are called "Notaufnahme" or "Notfallambulanz".

Access and Coverage for Free Healthcare in Germany

Who is covered under public healthcare in Germany?

All legal residents of Germany are required to have health insurance. The public healthcare system (GKV) covers:

1. German citizens
2. EU/EEA citizens
3. Non-EU residents with valid residence permits

The extent of services is generally the same for all users of the public system, with some co-payments required for certain services and medications.

Waiting times and availability of services in Germany

Germany generally has short waiting times for most healthcare services:

1. GP appointments: Usually available within a few days
2. Emergency care: Immediate
3. Specialist appointments: Can range from a few days to a few weeks
4. Elective surgeries: Waiting times are generally shorter than in many other European countries

Geographic disparities in healthcare access in Germany

While healthcare access is generally good across Germany, there can be some disparities:

1. Urban areas typically have a higher concentration of specialists and hospitals.
2. Rural areas may have fewer specialists, but primary care is widely available.
3. Some specialized treatments may require travel to larger cities or university hospitals.

Access and Coverage for Private Healthcare in Germany

Private insurance options

Several private health insurance providers operate in Germany, offering a range of plans with different levels of coverage and premiums. Some of the main providers include:

1. Allianz: One of the largest insurance companies in Germany, offering comprehensive health insurance plans.
2. DKV: Part of the ERGO Insurance Group, known for its wide range of health insurance options.
3. Debeka: A large insurance and financial services provider, popular among civil servants.
4. Signal Iduna: Offers various health insurance plans, including options for expats.

These insurers offer various plans catering to different needs and budgets. For example:

• Basic plans might cover inpatient and outpatient treatment
• Comprehensive plans could include additional benefits like dental care, alternative medicine, and international coverage
• Some plans offer the option to reduce premiums by agreeing to a deductible

The Federal Financial Supervisory Authority (BaFin) regulates the insurance industry in Germany.

Quality of Healthcare in Germany

Standards and regulations in Germany

Healthcare in Germany is regulated by several bodies to ensure high standards across both public and private sectors:

1. Federal Ministry of Health (Bundesministerium für Gesundheit): Responsible for health policy and legislation.
2. Federal Institute for Drugs and Medical Devices (BfArM): Regulates pharmaceuticals and medical devices.
3. Robert Koch Institute: The government's central scientific institution in the field of biomedicine.
4. German Medical Association (Bundesärztekammer): Represents the interests of the medical profession and ensures high standards of medical practice.

These bodies work together to maintain and improve the quality of healthcare services in Germany through regulations, inspections, and continuous professional development requirements for healthcare providers.

Comparison of public vs. private healthcare quality in Germany

Both public and private healthcare in Germany generally offer high-quality care:Public Healthcare (GKV):

1. Strengths: Comprehensive coverage, no upfront costs for most services, well-established network of providers.
2. Challenges: Some waiting times for non-urgent specialist appointments, less choice in certain treatments.

Private Healthcare (PKV):

1. Strengths: Potentially shorter waiting times, wider range of services, more personalized care.
2. Challenges: Can be more expensive, especially as one ages; may require upfront payment for services.

Quality Indicators:

• Life Expectancy: Germany's life expectancy is 81.1 years, above the OECD average.
• Infant Mortality: Germany has a low infant mortality rate of 3.2 per 1,000 live births.
• Cancer Survival Rates: Germany's cancer survival rates are generally high and above EU averages.

Overall, both public and private healthcare in Germany provide high-quality care, with the country consistently ranking among the top healthcare systems globally.

‍